What are the differences between KAGU and MAXTRAC liners? Kagu is our stylish carbon fiber-looking lightweight rubberized liner. Maxtrac has been designed to be more suitable for the outdoors, featuring a streamlined shape to prevent dirt and water, ensuring greater durability.

A: While all our floor liners are three layers, the main differences is the top layer. Kagu is our stylish carbon fiber looking lightweight rubberized liner. Elegant is our plush carpeted liner. Classic is our older carpeted liner that's being phased out for Elegant.

The Smartliners offer similar coverage as the Husky, while the Weathertechs just seem overpriced and have less coverage. Smartliners are made about on-par with Weathertech for thickness and feel/quality. Overall: 3/5 stars, go with Husky if you can't afford Smartliners.

Wrapping It Up. Thanks to the superior fit, additional coverage, non-slip, rubberized finish, and durable design, the Husky Liners® WeatherBeater™ is the clear winner in this comparison. WeatherTech® is a long-standing, trusted brand that was one of the original players in the custom-fitted floor mat marketplace.